Taking out the trash is good, no doubt, but there’s more to life than trash.
Let’s see now – a HBD “race realist” is opposed to pan-Europeanism and is hostile to White ethnics. Will wonders never cease? New breaking news: the sun will rise in the east tomorrow. Shocking! Unprecedented!
Seriously though, see this. That goes into the whole problem of confusing descriptive and prescriptive memes, as well as the problem in getting descriptives wrong in the first place.
And it goes deeper than this, to the very heart of the issue: EGI vs. HBD; Salter stressing genetic kinship (i.e., EGI) over some sort of hierarchical ranking of phenotypic traits (i.e., HBD).
Not surprisingly, HBDers are typically hostile to “Salterism.” HBD is a political movement dedicated to destroying White nationalism, with a long term goal of establishing polities ruled by Jews and Asians, with “First World White strains” as a subaltern stepandfetchit caste (and their woman as concubines for Jews and Asians). Now, that’s not what the HBDers overtly preach of course, and many of them would genuinely reject that proposition – but it doesn’t matter if the outcome is intentional or not; regardless, the eventual outcome of HBD politics will be the same whether it is from mendacity or just plain stupidity.
Interestingly, despite the fact that HBD is incompatible with WN, the “movement” has a strong HBD faction. Why so? Well, first, Der Movement activists are not too bright. Second, HBDers try to appeal to “First World strain” WNs by, essentially, patting them on the head and telling them how very, very Hajnal they all are. You’re part of the cogelite crowd, my friends! Ego-stroking is a powerful tool of memetic seduction. Third, many so-called WNs are not really racial nationalists at all, not in the way it is properly defined. These people support Whites only because they view Whites as the embodiment of certain traits; one can remember Jobling being a “pro-White activist” because Whites actualize Rawlsian liberalism.
So, there’s a lot of confusion and ideological incoherence in Der Movement (expected given the predominance of brain-addled Type I activists). Further, given the presence of a strong HBD faction along with a strong Nordicist faction (with some overlap between those groups), we have a situation that Der Movement really has not much of anything to offer to White ethnics. Racial nationalism however does indeed have much to offer to those groups; indeed, everything to offer, if survival is the ultimate interest (i.e., genetic continuity).
It is important not to confuse Der Movement with the concept of racial nationalism. An analogy would be the error of confusing the Republican Party has being the same as conservatism. No, the former is merely a vehicle for the latter, and a poor vehicle at that. Similarly, Der Movement is a pitifully pathetic vehicle for genuine racial nationalism, and a new vehicle is desperately required.
And, really, the amount of digital ink spilled over this tragicomic freak Faulk is disturbing. There are so any other things of importance to discuss and analyze that to waste time and effort on someone who is essentially speaking a different language, with a different and incompatible worldview is, frankly, disgusting. Why not tackle some of Salter’s more recent writings and analyses, for example?
Or, formulate your own worldview, instead of constantly “debunking” every memetic trash spewed forth from every and piece of flotsam and jetsam with an Internet connection.
There comes a time to advance and defend a strongly held position, a concrete and substantial worldview, instead of merely critiquing strawman misrepresentations of what others misconstrue what your position is (or should be). I’m guilty of this as well, to be honest. Certainly, this blog can benefit from more “what should be done” posts instead of “don’t do this.”
One final point for this post. It is a strawman representation of White nationalism to assert that WNs consider all Whites as part of their ingroup, they want every single White person as part of their erthnostate. No, every White person is potentially a part of the ingroup, but that depends on the people themselves as well. I’m not interested in SJW Whites, and am certainly not interested in White HBDers and other trash. Yes, we can try and convince, but in the end, why should we want to accept enemies? The idea is ludicrous.