Lies or stupidity – it’s anyone’s guess.
In all cases below, emphasis added.
Read this. After rehashing the points I made about Cheddar Man several days ago, we then get comments about Egyptians, ancient and modern, that are either mendacity or reflective of a problem with reading comprehension.
Today’s Egyptians have some sub-Saharan alleles, but this mixing appears to have begun only about 700 years ago.
The linked Nature article concerning that issue clearly states that the events of 700 years ago were in addition to the significant sub-Saharan ancestry that existed before:
The researchers say that there was probably a pulse of sub-Saharan African DNA into Egypt roughly 700 years ago. The mixing of ancient Egyptians and Africans from further south means that modern Egyptians can trace 8% more of their ancestry to sub-Saharan Africans than can the mummies from Abusir el-Meleq.
Got it? That’s 8% more than what was there before, not 8% suddenly appearing 700 years ago on a background of 0%.
The original paper:
…reveals that the three ancient Egyptians differ from modern Egyptians by a relatively larger Near Eastern genetic component, in particular a component found in Neolithic Levantine ancient…Finally, we used two methods to estimate the fractions of sub-Saharan African ancestry in ancient and modern Egyptians. Both qpAdm35 and the f4-ratio test39 reveal that modern Egyptians inherit 8% more ancestry from African ancestors than the three ancient Egyptians do, which is also consistent with the ADMIXTURE results discussed above. Absolute estimates of African ancestry using these two methods in the three ancient individuals range from 6 to 15%, and in the modern samples from 14 to 21% depending on method and choice of reference population
Got it? Moderns have ~8% more than the ancients, but the ancients may have been as high as 15%, with a floor of 6%.
So, what is the take home point? It is this: Der Movement, and particularly its HBD wing, LIES about race, LIES about population genetics, and LIES about racial history. Or, if you want to be more generous, they are not lying, but they are simply sincerely stupid, unable to read clear English, so they spread their wrong-headed misinformation around the Internet.
Thanks a lot for giving the Left ammunition to accuse racial activists of peddling pseudoscience about race. But, then, the HBDers do that a lot, don’t they? I don’t call them the Alt Wrong for nothing.
By the way, did you catch this from the original paper: “depending on method and choice of reference population.”
Sound familiar? Yes, it does.
Facts on race = EGI Notes
Falsehoods on race = Der Movement, Inc.